Like/Tweet/+1
Latest topics
» Cheddar Man lightened - where could he pass?
by Neon Knight Yesterday at 22:45

» Art Style Preferences Test
by Neon Knight Sun 18 Feb - 19:43

» What do you want from a political representative?
by Neon Knight Sat 17 Feb - 21:37

» Being bullied by siblings increases risk of psychosis
by Neon Knight Fri 16 Feb - 0:40

» Lauren Rose the American Ethno-Nationalist
by Neon Knight Thu 15 Feb - 18:17

» Red Ice Radio peddles junk science
by Neon Knight Thu 15 Feb - 18:13

» Neoliberal organisation recommends basic income policy
by Neon Knight Thu 15 Feb - 17:57

» M.E.T.A.L.
by Neon Knight Tue 13 Feb - 23:22

» A flag to represent European people?
by Neon Knight Sun 11 Feb - 13:48

» Is Sardinia in Europe or Africa?
by OsricPearl Sun 11 Feb - 4:44

» Beautiful Feminine Art
by OsricPearl Sun 11 Feb - 4:35

» British Family Names Finder
by Iseult Fri 9 Feb - 18:30

» Survey of Britons' Paranormal Beliefs (2017)
by Sary Fri 9 Feb - 11:31

» Bermuda becomes first country to repeal same-sex marriage
by Iseult Fri 9 Feb - 4:01

» Serbian politician fatally shot in Kosovo
by Magyar Lány Wed 7 Feb - 23:39

» King Michael: Romania bids farewell to former monarch
by Magyar Lány Wed 7 Feb - 23:06

» The Six European Microstates
by Neon Knight Wed 7 Feb - 19:13

» Tariq Ramadan charged in France over rape allegations
by OsricPearl Wed 7 Feb - 18:58

» Child slavery victim to plead to stay in UK with support of thousands
by Magyar Lány Wed 7 Feb - 18:13

» Traveling in USA
by OsricPearl Tue 6 Feb - 3:44

» The Christians Who Rejected the Old Testament
by Neon Knight Fri 2 Feb - 19:29

» Now listening to . . .
by Neon Knight Sun 28 Jan - 16:58

» Strong Quotes
by Neon Knight Sat 27 Jan - 17:50

» Melbourne councils scrap Australia Day but meet a backlash
by Aëlwenn Sat 27 Jan - 15:28

» Advertising authority to ban 'gender stereotypes'
by Neon Knight Wed 24 Jan - 8:43

» Woman loses job for supporting nationalist party
by Neon Knight Wed 24 Jan - 8:40

» The open plan office was a bad idea
by Neon Knight Sun 21 Jan - 1:00

» It's Father Christmas not Santa!
by Neon Knight Wed 17 Jan - 21:53

» Swiss campaign to end free movement with the EU
by Neon Knight Wed 17 Jan - 21:22

» The Roman Ghosts of Treasurer's House
by Neon Knight Mon 15 Jan - 8:51

» Maria the Soviet Lady Tank Warrior
by Neon Knight Sun 14 Jan - 22:44

» Has Viking settlement in England been underestimated?
by Neon Knight Fri 12 Jan - 22:25

» Opinions on this Inception (movie) scene?
by Neon Knight Wed 10 Jan - 23:18

» President Nixon considered nuking Vietnam in 1972
by de Burgh Tue 9 Jan - 18:53

» Trump says diplomacy with North Korea has failed
by Neon Knight Mon 8 Jan - 23:45

» New & Recent Film Trailers
by Sary Mon 8 Jan - 0:09

» Count Dankula's Court Hearings
by Neon Knight Mon 8 Jan - 0:08

» Movies who promote european culture
by Neon Knight Sun 7 Jan - 1:08

» Italy ojects to Austria's offer of passports to South Tyroleans
by Neon Knight Fri 5 Jan - 23:40

» Psychopaths & Sociopaths
by Neon Knight Fri 5 Jan - 0:27

» The French custom of cheek-kissing
by Neon Knight Fri 5 Jan - 0:01

» Higher temperatures linked to EU asylum figures
by Neon Knight Wed 3 Jan - 21:46

» Rare photo of Billy the Kid discovered
by Neon Knight Mon 1 Jan - 22:12

» Dead Bulgarian’s Prophecies Intrigue UK Media
by Sary Sun 31 Dec - 18:41

» Call for tech giants to face taxes over extremist content
by Magyar Lány Sun 31 Dec - 11:02

» Would future robots be given legal rights?
by Magyar Lány Wed 27 Dec - 20:42

» Ancestry Profiles of Norwegians
by Neon Knight Wed 27 Dec - 20:07

» Cthulhu Christmas Songs (tidings of madness and woe)
by Magyar Lány Sun 24 Dec - 23:23

» Dyker Heights Christmas Lights
by Neon Knight Sun 24 Dec - 0:17

» People of the British Isles + Irish DNA Atlas projects
by Aëlwenn Sat 23 Dec - 19:55


Has Viking settlement in England been underestimated?

View previous topic View next topic Go down

Has Viking settlement in England been underestimated?

Post Neon Knight on Fri 12 Jan - 22:25

http://sciencenordic.com/new-study-reignites-debate-over-viking-settlements-england

The Vikings plundered, raided, and eventually reigned over a large part of what is modern day England. But exactly how many Danish Vikings migrated west and settled down in the British Isles?

In 2015, a large DNA study sparked a row between DNA scientists and archaeologists after concluding that the Danish Vikings had a “relatively limited” influence on the British—a direct contradiction to archaeological remains and historical documents.“We see no clear genetic evidence of the Danish Viking occupation and control of a large part of England,” write DNA scientists in a study published in the scientific journal Nature in 2015.

A new study has reignited the debate by claiming that somewhere between 20,000 and 35,000 Vikings relocated to England.

“We don’t think that the Nature study analysis of the Danish Vikings is correct. We think that they incorrectly interpret the DNA material and that they don’t take into account all of the archaeological discoveries and the knowledge that historians and archaeologists have gathered concerning the Danish Vikings in England,” says co-author Jane Kershaw, an archaeologist and Viking researcher Jane Kershaw, a post doc at the University College London.

The new study is published in the archaeological journal Antiquity. In it, Kershaw and her colleague argue that evidence collected from language studies, written sources, and archaeological discoveries indicate a “large-scale Danish Viking presence in England,” says Kershaw.

The new result is pretty much what Viking researcher Søren Sindbæk, a professor at the School of Culture and Society from Aarhus University, Denmark, had expected. “It’s very interesting because it gives a very precise estimate of how many Vikings that moved to England. Both their analysis of the genetic material and archaeological remains indicate that the Danish Vikings had quite a significant influence,” says Sindbæk. “It all fits together beautifully and I’m in total agreement with their critique of the original DNA study conclusions about the Vikings,” he says.

Sindbæk was not involved in either of the two studies, but has closely followed the debate about the influence of Vikings in England. “20,000 to 35,000 Vikings moving to England might not sound like much to us. But remember that this was before flying, cellphones, and GPS. In the Viking times it was quite a significant migration,” says Sindbæk . . .

Kershaw was shocked when she read in British media that a new DNA study showed that Danish Vikings had very little influence on British genetics. “When I first read the Nature study I was a little shocked. I thought, “No, it simply doesn’t fit.” All of my own research is based on completely the opposite argument that there were a lot of Vikings—both men and women-- that settled in England,” says Kershaw.

She immediately called her friend Ellen Røyrvik, a geneticist at the University of Warwick, UK, who was one of the co-authors on the 2015 study. “Ellen explained that, in her opinion, there were many problems with the study’s interpretation of the DNA data concerning the Danish Vikings. This ended up being the reason why we collaborated to write a response, which is the study that’s just been published in Antiquity,” says Kershaw.

The original DNA study in Nature provides a genetic map of the British population and both Kershaw and Røyrvik stress that their criticism does not apply to the whole study—only to the conclusions that relates to the Danish Vikings. “The data are excellent, I just feel the interpretation is too simplistic,” says Røyrvik.

The Nature study concluded 20 per cent of the British DNA comes from the Anglo-Saxons who had come from Germany and invaded England in the 5th and 6th centuries. The study concluded that they largely mixed with the existing population. They concluded that it was difficult to isolate the influence of the Danish Vikings just by looking at the DNA material. “We’re quite confident that the Danish Vikings didn't leave much DNA in the UK population,” says Peter Donnelly, lead-author on the Nature study and director of the People of the British Isles project, which supplied the genetic data for the Nature study . . .

Their mistake, according to Røyrvik, is the way in which they differentiate between the Anglo-Saxon and Danish Viking DNA. A part of the genetic input that they describe as Anglo-Saxon actually probably has a Danish origin, she says.

“I think that the population that they think reflects Anglo-Saxons, also includes Danish Vikings. The arguments that they use to establish that it doesn’t apply to Danish Vikings don’t hold up,” says Røyrvik. She points out that the Anglo-Saxons invaded England in the 5th century, but they originally came from northern Germany, close to Jutland in West Denmark, where the Vikings later prospered. “It’s difficult to separate Danish Vikings and Anglo-Saxons genetically because these populations lived so close together. And at the same time, the Vikings arrived in England relatively soon after the Anglo-Saxons. This leads to extra uncertainty and it means that you can’t separate the two,” says Røyrvik . . .

DNA scientist Professor Rasmus Nielsen, from the Center for Theoretical Evolutionary Genomics at the University of California, Berkeley, USA, has read both the Nature study and the criticisms in the new Antiquity study. He emphasises that the Nature study methodology is both ground-breaking and innovative, but: “In relation to the part of the conclusions that relate to the Danish Vikings, I agree that they have probably pushed the interpretation of their results a bit further than what the data can support,” says Nielsen. “But I hope that this doesn’t overshadow that technically speaking, it’s a very impressive study,” he says.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Between the velvet lies, there's a truth that's hard as steel
The vision never dies, life's a never ending wheel
- R.J.Dio
avatar
Neon Knight
The Castellan

Male Posts : 764
Join date : 2017-03-05

http://castle-europa.forumotion.com

Back to top Go down

View previous topic View next topic Back to top

- Similar topics

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum