Like/Tweet/+1
Latest topics
» Now listening to . . .
by Neon Knight Today at 0:56

» Animals - News & General
by Sary Yesterday at 10:55

» Front National / Rassemblement National
by Neon Knight Wed 14 Nov - 18:16

» Hitler's friendship with a part Jewish child
by Neon Knight Wed 14 Nov - 1:21

» Italian 'land-for-children' idea to increase birth rate
by Sary Mon 5 Nov - 22:41

» 12 Common French Gestures
by Sary Mon 5 Nov - 22:21

» White majorities feel threatened [good article]
by Neon Knight Mon 5 Nov - 20:40

» Germany's AfD Party
by Neon Knight Sun 4 Nov - 22:00

» There's only 11 mins of play in an American football game
by Jehan I Sat 3 Nov - 13:06

» Song Cover-Versions & Originals
by Neon Knight Sat 3 Nov - 1:38

» English Teen Kidnapped for 12 years
by Jehan I Fri 2 Nov - 18:56

» Old Film Trailers (to 2009)
by Neon Knight Wed 31 Oct - 22:09

» Classic TV Adverts
by Neon Knight Wed 31 Oct - 21:26

» European Royalty
by Neon Knight Wed 31 Oct - 21:12

» Halloween Customs of Scotland
by Neon Knight Wed 31 Oct - 20:50

» British New Zealander politician cannot understand Scottish accent
by OsricPearl Mon 29 Oct - 13:32

» Personality traits linked to political orientation
by Neon Knight Tue 23 Oct - 14:00

» Favourite Film Scenes
by Neon Knight Fri 19 Oct - 19:13

» Opinion survey on gene editing
by Sary Fri 19 Oct - 2:00

» More Madness from America - The Fake Indian
by OsricPearl Thu 18 Oct - 3:28

» Students to lecture profs. on diversity
by Neon Knight Tue 16 Oct - 21:45

» A flag to represent European people?
by Sary Sun 14 Oct - 1:30

» How do you write these numbers in words?
by OsricPearl Sat 13 Oct - 22:41

» UK Migration Issues
by Neon Knight Sat 13 Oct - 22:09

» Radio hostess banned for 'safe space' joke
by Neon Knight Wed 10 Oct - 23:56

» Beautiful Feminine Art
by OsricPearl Wed 10 Oct - 2:50

» Supreme Court Clown Car of Witches
by Neon Knight Mon 8 Oct - 20:26

» Defence Spending - NATO and Others
by Neon Knight Sun 7 Oct - 21:17

» Jirel of Joiry - the first female fantasy warrior
by OsricPearl Fri 5 Oct - 18:10

» Accounts of Apparitions
by Neon Knight Fri 5 Oct - 1:08

» London Street Scenes 1967
by Neon Knight Sun 30 Sep - 23:20

» American/British/German Attitudes to Military Heroism
by Sary Sun 30 Sep - 22:30

» Africa’s dangerous baby boom
by Neon Knight Sat 29 Sep - 18:03

» Waterfalls of Iceland
by Neon Knight Thu 27 Sep - 21:16

» What it takes to be superhuman
by Sary Sat 22 Sep - 1:22

» France nearly restored its monarchy in 1871
by Iseult Mon 17 Sep - 7:23

» Sweden votes tomorrow
by OsricPearl Sun 16 Sep - 15:39

» Rise of Nationalist Parties in Europe
by OsricPearl Sat 15 Sep - 18:30

» The Society for Creative Anachronism and a Swastika Controversy
by Neon Knight Fri 14 Sep - 22:35

» Project to put Sadiq Khan balloon over London
by Neon Knight Mon 3 Sep - 17:22


The Evacuation of Dunkirk in 1940

Reply to topic

View previous topic View next topic Go down

The Evacuation of Dunkirk in 1940

Post Neon Knight on Thu 21 Sep - 1:38

The new film has put this piece of history in the news, so here are a few short videos about it:








----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Between the velvet lies, there's a truth that's hard as steel
The vision never dies, life's a never ending wheel
- R.J.Dio
avatar
Neon Knight
The Castellan

Male Posts : 1172
Join date : 2017-03-05

http://castle-europa.forumotion.com

Back to top Go down

Re: The Evacuation of Dunkirk in 1940

Post Neon Knight on Wed 4 Oct - 23:20


----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Between the velvet lies, there's a truth that's hard as steel
The vision never dies, life's a never ending wheel
- R.J.Dio
avatar
Neon Knight
The Castellan

Male Posts : 1172
Join date : 2017-03-05

http://castle-europa.forumotion.com

Back to top Go down

Re: The Evacuation of Dunkirk in 1940

Post Aëlwenn on Mon 23 Oct - 17:21

The Nolan's movie is piece of shit, real shame and an insult.
After watching the film, I understand why many people complain about it here.
avatar
Aëlwenn
La dame du château

Female Posts : 161
Join date : 2017-06-23

Back to top Go down

Re: The Evacuation of Dunkirk in 1940

Post Aëlwenn on Wed 25 Oct - 1:34

I just realized that my last message was quite virulent and without explanation.
Two reasons why I do not like Nolan's film:

-I usually like Nolan's films, especially Interstellar, one of my favorite movies, adoring space, technology, the question of life elsewhere, this movie is really exciting (and the music is sublime) . I love Memento a lot too.
The one in Dunkirk, which was realized in Dunkirk by the way, of numerous errors unworthy of Nolan.At certain times of the film, we see buildings in the background, dating from 2010.
A public trash sorting is visible, and top of all, many times have can see antennas 4G!
I think it's Nolan's first movie with so many mistakes.

-The second reason is general, and much talked about in France.
That Nolan chooses to focus on seven soldiers in particular, make the film intimate, no worries.
From the British point of view, what's more normal.
This is a highlight of the Second World War and modern British history. The beginning of a heroic resistance, The Battle of Britain (I am passionate about the battle of England since my uncle took me to see a Spitfire in action).

But where it becomes offensive, as French, it is the treatment of French troops precisely.

To get into precision, the evacuation of Dunkirk is 340,000 soldiers.
Among these soldiers, 130,000 were French, or 39% of the troops.
And in the movies, where are they? Nowhere, neither on the beach nor on the ships.
The only French soldier we see is represented as a coward ... cliché well known Anglo-Saxon on the French military.

To allow the evacuation of troops on the beach, 40,000 French soldiers are staying in the town of Dunkirk to fight and prevent the German soldiers from taking the beach. The Germans numbered 160,000.
Of these 40,000 French, 18,000 died, a real sacrifice.
35,000 are taken prisoner and sent to the camps.
In the movies, no treatment on this part, if not a slight allusion to the end ...

And for the evacuation itself, in the film all the boarding is English, fishermen and other civilians.
In reality, only 10% of the ships were civilian.
And in reality, 300 French ships participated in the evacuation, including three destroyers that were sunk.
No mention in the movies.

Many spectators in France were disappointed, because they felt a lack of respect for this part of the History, and in France a big fed the bowl for the Anglo Saxon mockery on this subject, you know, the "Stupid eating surrender monkeys" ...
In 1940, 60,000 French soldiers died in six weeks, 123,000 were wounded and 2 million were taken prisoner. 21,000 civilians, including many women and children, are killed.
A record higher than the Battle of Verdun, which made 163,000 deaths in ten months.

So this is not a criticism of this episode of the Second World War, very far from it (my primary school received each year English and Scottish veterans who participated in the liberation of our city).
I have immense respect for the courage of these men, who died for freedom, and for Europe.
I also have a deep admiration for the courage and resistance of the British, alone in the face of the Nazi ogre, and the ingenuity they have deployed in the fight against Hitler (breaking the Enigma code, radar, the courage of their pilots).
But it's really Nolan's movie that I find a shame and dishonest to History.
avatar
Aëlwenn
La dame du château

Female Posts : 161
Join date : 2017-06-23

Back to top Go down

Re: The Evacuation of Dunkirk in 1940

Post Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

View previous topic View next topic Back to top

- Similar topics

Permissions in this forum:
You can reply to topics in this forum