Like/Tweet/+1
Latest topics
» I wrote a novel
by OsricPearl Yesterday at 17:36

» Now listening to . . .
by Sary Yesterday at 1:37

» Monty Python Scenes & Sketches
by Sary Yesterday at 1:19

» The Best Castles in Great Britain
by Sary Yesterday at 1:04

» New Genetic Study of the French
by Sary Sun 15 Sep - 22:01

» Are Scots still against independence?
by Neon Knight Sun 15 Sep - 18:24

» Turkey threatens to re-open migration route
by Neon Knight Fri 13 Sep - 0:11

» Switzerland votes for tighter gun laws
by Neon Knight Thu 12 Sep - 21:06

» Brexit Saga Update
by Neon Knight Tue 10 Sep - 1:50

» Representative Democracy
by Neon Knight Thu 5 Sep - 22:30

» Animals - News & General
by Neon Knight Wed 28 Aug - 23:34

» The White Rose Group of Nazi Germany
by Neon Knight Mon 26 Aug - 9:46

» Folklore of Iberia
by Neon Knight Fri 23 Aug - 0:33

» Favourite Film & TV Scenes
by Neon Knight Wed 21 Aug - 23:41

» Old Film Trailers (to 2009)
by Neon Knight Sat 10 Aug - 23:18

» Horns are growing on young people's skulls. Phone use is to blame, research suggests.
by Sary Wed 7 Aug - 0:19

» UK Migration Issues
by Neon Knight Tue 6 Aug - 9:55

» Greek Tragedy by a Computer Program
by OsricPearl Tue 6 Aug - 2:58

» Polish soldier & nurse reunited after almost 75 years
by Sary Sun 4 Aug - 20:30

» Countries with the most & the best English speakers
by Neon Knight Tue 30 Jul - 22:26

» Moscow: 20,000 demand fair elections
by Neon Knight Sat 27 Jul - 0:04

» Real Time Lightning Map
by OsricPearl Thu 25 Jul - 22:52

» Song Cover-Versions & Originals
by Neon Knight Thu 25 Jul - 0:49

» Should American conservatives reject libertarianism?
by Sary Sun 21 Jul - 11:39

» Athens earthquake - 5.1
by Neon Knight Sun 21 Jul - 3:49

» Rent Seeking - Economic Concept
by OsricPearl Mon 15 Jul - 21:34

» Tommy Robinson
by Neon Knight Sat 13 Jul - 1:51

» Historical European Martial Arts, Arms & Armour
by Sary Thu 11 Jul - 12:53

» Marble head of Dionysus discovered under Rome
by OsricPearl Wed 10 Jul - 20:21

» The regional flags/emblems of you and your ancestors
by Sary Sat 6 Jul - 1:43

» The meaning of 'fair'- light or beautiful?
by OsricPearl Fri 5 Jul - 19:38

» When is incitement direct and indirect?
by Neon Knight Tue 2 Jul - 1:00

» Huge Aquifer found under the Atlantic
by Neon Knight Thu 27 Jun - 0:31

» Drunk Polish man invades Polish village with a Soviet Tank
by OsricPearl Wed 26 Jun - 0:25

» WWII bomb in London
by Sary Wed 26 Jun - 0:16

» 1,700-year-old Roman coin sells for £550,000
by Sary Tue 25 Jun - 21:50

» Beautiful Feminine Art
by Neon Knight Sun 23 Jun - 2:08

» At Historic Hearing, House Panel Explores Reparations
by Neon Knight Thu 20 Jun - 22:17

» Opinions on National Identity by Country
by OsricPearl Thu 13 Jun - 5:00

» Denmark's New Government
by Sary Thu 13 Jun - 0:27


The genetic argument against race - how good is it?

Reply to topic

View previous topic View next topic Go down

The genetic argument against race - how good is it? Empty The genetic argument against race - how good is it?

Post Neon Knight on Fri 7 Jun - 17:17

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/magazine/2018/04/race-genetics-science-africa/

"In June 2000, when the results were announced at a White House ceremony, Craig Venter, a pioneer of DNA sequencing, observed, 'The concept of race has no genetic or scientific basis.'"

"Over the past few decades, genetic research has revealed two deep truths about people. The first is that 1 all humans are closely related—more closely related than all chimps, even though there are many more humans around today. Everyone has the same collection of genes, but with the exception of identical twins, everyone has slightly different versions of some of them. Studies of this genetic diversity have allowed scientists to reconstruct a kind of family tree of human populations. That has revealed the second deep truth: In a very real sense, 2 all people alive today are Africans."

"'That race is a human construction doesn’t mean that we don’t fall into different groups or there’s no variation,” Foeman says. “But if we made racial categories up, maybe we can make new categories that function better.'"


-------------------------------------------------

You'll notice that last statement back-pedals a quite a bit on the first one i.e. we do fall into different groups and there is variation between them. But let's examine those two points anyway.

Some facts relating to statement 1:

Of the genetic variance in dogs, 65% is within breeds and 31% is between breeds.
Of the genetic variance in cats, 84% is within breeds and 16% is between breeds.
Of the genetic variance in humans, 85% is within types an 10% is between types.

So humans are similar to cats in this regard. No one thinks that a Siamese cat is a different species to a Persian but they are clearly different breeds or races. And I'm sure cat fans think these group differences are meaningful.

About statement 2 https://doi.org/10.1093/gbe/evu027 :

East Asians are estimated to have diverged from Africans about 55,000 years ago and Europeans from East Asians approximately 41,000 years ago.

It's now believed the original migration from Africa was about 185,000 years ago, but we're all still Africans? Jester That might mean something as scientific data but science doesn't say anything about meaning, and in terms of human history and everything that's happened, it makes little sense to say we are all Africans. Even the present day Africans can't be the same as those from that prehistoric time.




The genetic argument against race - how good is it? Englan11

Between the velvet lies, there's a truth that's hard as steel
The vision never dies, life's a never ending wheel
- R.J.Dio
Neon Knight
Neon Knight
The Castellan

Male Posts : 1538
Join date : 2017-03-05

http://castle-europa.forumotion.com

Back to top Go down

The genetic argument against race - how good is it? Empty Re: The genetic argument against race - how good is it?

Post Iseult on Sun 9 Jun - 5:33

you can even reconstruct someone's FACE SHAPE based on their DNA. To say race doesn't exist genetically is beyond asinine

Iseult

Female Posts : 21
Join date : 2017-06-03

Back to top Go down

The genetic argument against race - how good is it? Empty Re: The genetic argument against race - how good is it?

Post Neon Knight on Tue 11 Jun - 0:15

@Iseult wrote:you can even reconstruct someone's FACE SHAPE based on their DNA. To say race doesn't exist genetically is beyond asinine
And you can tell apart European and African skulls with 80% accuracy. This is new:
https://medium.com/@NoahCarl/are-racial-classifications-arbitrary-ac53cb43de90?postPublishedType=initial

"Bo Winegard and I wrote a review of Angela Saini’s new book, Superior: The Return of Race Science, which provoked a rather hostile reaction from some people on Twitter. Unsurprisingly, the vast majority of criticisms were ad hominem attacks against us, or against the publisher, Quillette. You know, it was the usual stuff: ‘racist’, ‘fascist’, ‘Nazi’, etc. However, there were a few criticisms that went beyond simple name-calling, and I would like to respond to those here . . . Moreover, when all the various sub-populations are plotted on a principal components graph, the major continental populations are clearly separable. (Note that their separation would be even clearer if the third principal component were plotted too.)"

The genetic argument against race - how good is it? 1ptd2p11




The genetic argument against race - how good is it? Englan11

Between the velvet lies, there's a truth that's hard as steel
The vision never dies, life's a never ending wheel
- R.J.Dio
Neon Knight
Neon Knight
The Castellan

Male Posts : 1538
Join date : 2017-03-05

http://castle-europa.forumotion.com

Back to top Go down

The genetic argument against race - how good is it? Empty Re: The genetic argument against race - how good is it?

Post Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

View previous topic View next topic Back to top

- Similar topics

Permissions in this forum:
You can reply to topics in this forum