Like/Tweet/+1
Latest topics
» On the Iraq border archaeological digs are a minefield – in every sense
by Neon Knight Today at 0:08

» Huntswoman thrashes saboteur with a riding crop
by Magyar Lány Yesterday at 23:53

» German coalition talks collapse
by Magyar Lány Yesterday at 19:23

» London buses to be powered by coffee grounds
by Neon Knight Yesterday at 2:57

» The Dwarves
by Aëlwenn Yesterday at 1:53

» Serbian Presidency Rejects Any Takeover of Bosnian Serb Land
by Magyar Lány Yesterday at 1:25

» Brexit: EU gives May two weeks to act on divorce bill and Ireland
by Aëlwenn Yesterday at 1:16

» Plague reached Europe by Stone Age
by Magyar Lány Wed 22 Nov - 20:43

» Guess a group of men & women
by OsricPearl Wed 22 Nov - 1:48

» Germany Arrests 6 Syrian Migrants Suspected of ISIS Links
by Neon Knight Tue 21 Nov - 21:35

» Now listening to . . .
by Magyar Lány Tue 21 Nov - 9:38

» To any guests viewing the forum
by Neon Knight Mon 20 Nov - 21:32

» Amsterdam to be new home of European Medicines Agency
by Magyar Lány Mon 20 Nov - 20:49

» Monty Python Scenes & Sketches
by Neon Knight Sun 19 Nov - 23:43

» London - travel video
by Neon Knight Sun 19 Nov - 10:37

» Spain's Director Of Public Prosecutions, José Manuel Maza, Dies Unexpectedly In Buenos Aires Following Infection
by Magyar Lány Sun 19 Nov - 10:31

» Two timelapse videos of Paris
by Magyar Lány Sun 19 Nov - 10:28

» Russian Ministry Urges Heavy Prison Sentences For Importing Western Produce
by Magyar Lány Sun 19 Nov - 10:15

» Facebook was designed to be addictive
by Magyar Lány Sun 19 Nov - 0:25

» It's True Alcohol Helps You Speak a Foreign Language Better
by Neon Knight Sun 19 Nov - 0:13

» Albania Red-Faced Over Soldiers Deserting in UK
by Neon Knight Sat 18 Nov - 11:49

» Hungary accuses US of meddling by funding ‘objective’ media
by Guest Fri 17 Nov - 18:39

» The EU Army
by Neon Knight Wed 15 Nov - 22:37

» Northern & Southern English Accents
by Neon Knight Wed 15 Nov - 22:27

» Budapest timelapse
by Neon Knight Wed 15 Nov - 22:19

» Portugal exits EU's budget deficit watchlist
by OsricPearl Wed 15 Nov - 17:56

» Traveling in USA
by OsricPearl Wed 15 Nov - 17:45

» Muslim preacher gave sermons encouraging terrorism
by Neon Knight Wed 15 Nov - 9:39

» Canada
by Armelle Wed 15 Nov - 5:28

» Northern Lights seen from Great Britain
by Neon Knight Wed 15 Nov - 1:39

» World Scientists Warning the Humanity: A second Notice
by Neon Knight Wed 15 Nov - 1:21

» Sir James Dyson " Make easier hire fire people with brexit"
by Neon Knight Mon 13 Nov - 23:25

» Will go to Sweden
by Jehan I Mon 13 Nov - 21:34

» Environmentalism is Facism
by Guest Mon 13 Nov - 10:41

» Denmark has the world's oldest tattoo shop
by Jack Hawait Mon 13 Nov - 7:27

» Spain's Rajoy in Catalonia campaign visit after big protest
by Guest Sun 12 Nov - 15:42

» Warsaw nationalist march draws tens of thousands
by Guest Sun 12 Nov - 10:57

» Favorite sports?
by Neon Knight Sun 12 Nov - 10:28

» Where should Europe's eastern border lie?
by Guest Fri 10 Nov - 20:59

» British farms could be wasteland in 30 years
by Aëlwenn Fri 10 Nov - 14:38

» Song Cover-Versions & Originals
by Neon Knight Fri 10 Nov - 0:18

» Rate the above song /10 (2nd & 3rd opinions allowed)
by Neon Knight Thu 9 Nov - 22:52

» Melbourne councils scrap Australia Day but meet a backlash
by Guest Wed 8 Nov - 0:22

» Robin who? Folk stories at risk of dying out
by Neon Knight Tue 7 Nov - 17:51

» The Gunpowder Plot of 1605 - facts & a good TV documentary
by Neon Knight Sun 5 Nov - 18:04

» Middle Earth in the real world
by Sary Sat 4 Nov - 15:51

» Poles launch petition against plan to remove cross in Breton town
by Aëlwenn Fri 3 Nov - 17:53

» The America-British Pig War of 1859
by Neon Knight Thu 2 Nov - 19:44

» Computer program can tell if people are straight or gay from a photo
by Neon Knight Wed 1 Nov - 20:23

» English county bans unstunned halal meat from all school meals
by OsricPearl Tue 31 Oct - 18:58


Racially aggravated crime - does it make sense?

View previous topic View next topic Go down

Racially aggravated crime - does it make sense?

Post Neon Knight on Sun 15 Oct - 1:57

Imagine the following scenario:


Two half drunk white men cross the street and begin an unprovoked attack on a black man. White Man A shouts several racial insults during the attack. White Man B, though just as physically aggressive, says nothing.

The crime is reported, the two white men are tried and found guilty of Actual Bodily Harm. Both are sent to prison but Man A is also found guilty of a racially aggravated offence:

"The offender demonstrating towards the victim of the offence hostility based on the victim's membership (or presumed membership) of a racial or religious group"

And so he is given a longer prison sentence than Man A . . .

"In addition to the specific offences created by the Act, the law imposes a general duty on criminal courts, when sentencing an offender, to treat more seriously any offence which can be shown to be racially or religiously aggravated (Section 145 Criminal Justice Act 2003)"


Is the longer sentence for Man A logical or should his racial insults at the victim have made no difference to the seriousness of his crime?

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Between the velvet lies, there's a truth that's hard as steel
The vision never dies, life's a never ending wheel
- R.J.Dio
avatar
Neon Knight
The Castellan

Male Posts : 530
Join date : 2017-03-05

http://castle-europa.forumotion.com

Back to top Go down

.

Post Guest on Sun 15 Oct - 22:00

@Neon Knight wrote:Imagine the following scenario:


Two half drunk white men cross the street and begin an unprovoked attack on a black man. White Man A shouts several racial insults during the attack. White Man B, though just as physically aggressive, says nothing.

The crime is reported, the two white men are tried and found guilty of Actual Bodily Harm. Both are sent to prison but Man A is also found guilty of a racially aggravated offence:

"The offender demonstrating towards the victim of the offence hostility based on the victim's membership (or presumed membership) of a racial or religious group"

And so he is given a longer prison sentence than Man A . . .

"In addition to the specific offences created by the Act, the law imposes a general duty on criminal courts, when sentencing an offender, to treat more seriously any offence which can be shown to be racially or religiously aggravated (Section 145 Criminal Justice Act 2003)"


Is the longer sentence for Man A logical or should his racial insults at the victim have made no difference to the seriousness of his crime?

Strange decision. White Man A offended the black guy's dignity, too, that's why it sounds logical.

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

View previous topic View next topic Back to top

- Similar topics

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum